Matthew’s death, in the Urban Assembly School for Wildlife Conservation, was the first in New York City schools in decades. The story received substantial coverage, but his teachers and friends say the media missed the real story.
“If this were Parkland, the media would have never stopped asking why,” says Christopher Vasquez, who taught Matthew at the Bronx school. “They painted it like [Matthew] was the perp, like he was a thug. Fit it to their stereotypes and forgot about it.”
Vasquez connected me with eight of Matthew’s teachers and six of Matthew’s friends. They say he was not a bully but a very “respectful kid” and “wicked smart.”
They wanted to not only set the record straight on Matthew, but on UA Wildlife, a once-safe school that fell into chaos as new administrators implemented a new approach to school discipline.
New York was on the vanguard of a nationwide movement, spurred largely through federal coercion, to undo traditional discipline in favor of a progressive or “restorative” approach.
“The kids quickly realized their teachers could get in trouble for getting them in trouble.”
Friends of school stabbing victim wear t-shirts with his face to courtwide movement, spurred largely through federal coercion, to undo traditional discipline in favor of a progressive or “restorative” approach.
At UA Wildlife, meaningful consequences for misbehavior were eliminated, alternative approaches failed, and administration responded to a rising tide of disorder and violence by sweeping evidence of it under the rug. If the administrators had prioritized student safety over statistics, Matthew’s teachers believe he would still be alive.
And they fear the dynamics that destroyed UA Wildlife are playing out across New York City.
UA Wildlife, which serves approximately 450 students in grades 6-12, was founded in 2007 as a traditional public school with support from the Urban Assembly nonprofit.
Five years ago, under the leadership of founding principal, Mark Ossenheimer, it was a thriving school with engaged students and a passionate faculty. According to the NYC School Survey, 86 percent of teachers said order and discipline were maintained, and 80 percent of students said they felt safe in the hallways.
A senior recalls, “Sixth-eighth grade was honestly the best school years of my life. We had the best staff [and] the best students.”
But by the 2016-17 school year, most of the old faculty had fled. Only 19 percent of teachers said order was maintained, and only 55 percent of students said they felt safe. Rumors of weapons were omnipresent, and fights were a matter of weekly, if not daily, routine.
How did conditions deteriorate so quickly?
Back in the 2013-14 year, then-dean Hector Diaz commanded the respect of the students. “He was strict, ex-military. He would take no crap from them,” says one teacher.
The senior says, “Mr. Diaz was a strict person indeed, but he was also a caring dean. Nobody would mess around when he was dean ’cause they realize the consequences were not good.”
But Diaz “didn’t even have to suspend” very much, a teacher says, because the kids knew he meant business and whenever they were suspended, they “were like, ‘Nah, I don’t want to be out again. I don’t want to do that again.’ ”
At first, UA Wildlife resisted the shift. One teacher recalls that when the central office started “kicking suspensions back,” the “dean was like, ‘This is what I have to do, and I’ll do it,’ and he did.”
But the next school year, a new leader, Latir Primus, took the helm. Without tenure, Primus was under pressure to meet the expectation of his superiors. Primus boasted in his school’s comprehensive education plan that the “school has low incidents of behavioral problems as evident in their suspension data.” But lower suspension data can be quite easily achieved by simply not enforcing rules.
When Vasquez told a student to get off her phone or see Vice Principal Daniel Pichardo, the student left class and returned to announce that “Pichardo says it’s OK, I can stay on my phone.”
“How are you going to tell me that I need to write rules, then the second I try to enforce those rules you take away my credibility?” Vasquez asks.
The kids quickly realized their teachers could get in trouble for getting them in trouble. Vasquez shared a video he took of his classroom. Two girls are standing in front of the class, talking loudly. When Vasquez asks them to return to their seats, one yells “I’m gonna stand right here! You not tellin’ me nothing! Mr. Primus not tellin’ me nothing! None of them teachers tellin’ me nothing! So I’m gonna stand right there!” The other girl chimes in, “I’ll take you to court!”
At UA Wildlife, the “restorative” approach accelerated the school’s disintegration. “Instead of suspending the kids, they made this group called the Warriors,” says one teacher. “It was all the kids that needed discipline, and they did this social-justice program, and it kind of backfired on them.”
Instead of punishment for bad behavior, the Warriors were rewarded for good behavior, given special attention, personal lunches and a 15-minute pass to leave class to “de-stress.” They used this last perk as an excuse to cut class, and this all started making well-behaved students resentful.
The school dropped the restorative Warriors program and began a Positive Behavioral Intervention System, offering students tickets redeemable for prizes in exchange for good behavior. “But the students didn’t value them,” Vasquez says, “so that system failed, as well.”
Vasquez explains that after each failure, administrators blamed teachers for not “implementing” it correctly. “The worst and biggest waste of time was advisory lessons on how to be responsible,” he says. “Making posters around the school like, ‘Take off your headphones.’ None of the students took that seriously because they knew no one could follow through.”
“The easiest way to get discipline numbers down is to not enforce discipline. And on the rare occasion you have no other choice, take discipline off the books.”
No one could follow through because the administration received documentation of a behavioral problem, but didn’t act on it. Teachers were expected to enter “anecdotal” logs of good and bad behavior in Skedula, the school’s student-tracking software system.
Midway through the 2015-16 year, Principal Primus was replaced by Astrid Jacobo. Whereas several teachers had kind words for Primus, none had even one for Jacobo.
“I remember one time, this was right when she started,” says one teacher. “There was one student who was cursing in the hallway. Jacobo comes up very calmly, puts her hand on her shoulder, and says, ‘We don’t curse in this school.’ The girl yanked her shoulder away saying, ‘Get off me, b- - -h.’ She did that. Fine. What’s the result? Nothing. She didn’t get detention. Nothing.”
After that incident and others like it, says a student, “Nobody listened to Jacobo. She would threaten us at first with detention or suspension, and she wouldn’t do it. This caused students to ignore her.”
Facing with increasingly unruly students and a hostile administration, teachers fled. “Mass exodus,” one teacher says.
Some teachers stopped recording misbehavior on Skedula, seeing no point. Others continued, hoping against hope for support that never came. The following logs, from the 2016-17 year, give a flavor of daily life at UA Wildlife:
Log 14873: “Today [name redacted] came into my class during a class that wasn’t his and smacked me in my face very hard.”
Log 1713: “[Name Redacted] and [name redacted] came in to my 3rd period English class and when I closed the door to have them leave [name redacted] stated ‘I’m gonna knock you out one day!’ ”
Log 18220: “When I went to change the power point [name redacted] told me to not change ‘the f- -king slide’ and that is I did change the f- -king slide she would ‘f- -king slap me on the side of my f- -king head.’ ”
Log 17119: “[Name redacted] was asked to put away his phone and do his work. He then proceeded to threaten [name redacted] and myself. He informed us that we were ‘c- -k sucking a- -holes’ and that ‘I will beat the f- -k out of you two on the last day of school.’ Threats should not be tolerated. I will attempt a parent call. Prior calls have not worked. ”
“So Matthew starts coming around. Mr. Jacoby tries to push him back, he’s like, ‘No, you don’t have to do . . .’ Then, Matthew like just literally passes right by Mr. Jacoby and starts going toward him. That was when Abel pulls out the black switchblade and he was like, ‘Pull up, run up, run up.’ Right?
“Then Matthew. I don’t know if he saw it or not. But as soon as everybody saw it in the front, they started backing up. And we were, like, screaming, ‘Matthew, don’t do it!’ And he still kept going. He landed mad hits on him. And then that was when he got stabbed.
“And he, it looked like Abel was just punching him in the stomach, but he was stabbing. So when he got off of him, all you saw was, like, blood. And Matthew looked down to hold it, kind of. He didn’t look down. He just went to hold it. And that was when he looked down. And then he went to go and keep going.
“But his body just collapsed on the floor kind of after Alex was like, ‘Bro, you need to stop,’ but he kept going. And that was when he face-planted onto the floor.”
Asked whether she saw any red flags at UA Wildlife, then-Schools Chancellor Carmen Fariña said, “I don’t think that that was something that was really apparent.”
The scary thing is that it wasn’t. In a school district that serves more than a million students, a central office operates based on data. Aside from the student surveys, the data showed that things were fine. Because Fariña’s policies were designed to make the data look fine by pressuring principals to get the suspension rates down. For new principals without tenure, like Primus and Jacobo, the pressure becomes particularly acute.
The easiest way to get discipline numbers down is to not enforce discipline. And on the rare occasion you have no other choice, take discipline off the books. Students and teachers allege that administrators did just this, simply telling students to go home for a few days.
In Washington, DC, a Freedom of Information Act request of school e-mails revealed that high-school principals systematically hid suspensions from district administrators. A similar FOIA request at UA Wildlife would have come up empty: Jacobo pressured teachers against sending e-mails on official servers.
A few weeks after the Matthew’s slaying, the records of Matthew McCree and Abel Cedeno were locked on Skedula. Shortly thereafter, Skedula was overhauled. Years of data were deleted, and the new version at UA Wildlife records data for 14 days, then deletes it. After those changes were made, teachers say they were instructed not to put any discipline information on Skedula. It all goes on paper.
“So I’m going to fill it out, give it to you, you take it, throw it in the garbage, and call it a day?” one teacher says. “That’s just incorrigible.”
This shift in software and standard practice was not confined to UA Wildlife. The Post reported that the dean of JHS 80 in The Bronx “warned faculty about posting reports of student misconduct and disturbances on Skedula.” The reason? Because if the DOE reads those reports, “the higher-ups will ‘come after’ the school’s management, and question teachers’ performance, with reason to say ‘gotcha.’ ”
If teachers can’t access records of student behavior, Vasquez notes, then “who knows how many reports like the one about Abel bringing a knife just aren’t in the system anymore?”
Matthew’s death brought no accountability, and no change. Jacobo was not fired but reassigned to provide support to other school administrators. UA Wildlife became no safer. In January, a student spoke out on social media:
“You’d think that because of what happened our school would be safer, right? Nope, tell me why and how it was possible for 2 people not even from our school came into the school with knives and ran around with it. They didn’t even make students aware of this nor did they call for a lock down. What if they went around stabbing people who were unaware of their presence? Then what would they have said/done? So sick and tired of this school.”
