Manhattan Institute for Policy Research.
Subscribe   Subscribe   MI on Facebook Find us on Twitter Find us on Instagram      

San Francisco Examiner


Education Policies Fail Brilliant Young Multi-Instrumentalist

June 12, 2011

By Diana Furchtgott-Roth

Meet 18-year-old Josh Coyne, a brilliant musician who will graduate Monday from Winston Churchill High School in Potomac, Md.

Josh plays violin, viola, saxophone and piano. He composed the score for “Anne & Emmett,” an acclaimed play. He conducted the premiere of his ballet “True Love,” and was selected by Bethesda (Md.) Magazine as one of 10 winners of its annual Extraordinary Teen Awards.

Josh has played his violin for Vice President Joe Biden and Attorney General Eric Holder, and a documentary is being filmed about him called “Prodigy.”

Former Secretary of Defense William Cohen wrote in a recommendation, “I believe that Joshua is one of the great young talents of America, and has a future that is unlimited in scope and depth.”

One might think that Josh has every opportunity open before him.

But Josh faces the problem of thousands of other young Americans: His single mother, Jane Coyne (who adopted him at age 2), doesn’t earn enough at her job with the National PTA to send him to college.

Josh has been admitted to one of America’s leading conservatories, the Manhattan School of Music. It’s a four-year program, where he’s one of only two entering students admitted to major in composition.

Josh has been given a scholarship from the conservatory covering $25,000 of the $53,000 in annual fees. The federal Pell grant, the work-study program, two kinds of Stafford loans, the Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant, and the Perkins loan bring in another $11,800.

However, Josh’s acceptance letter states that the conservatory expects his family to use the U.S. Department of Education’s Direct Parent Plus loan to pay for the remaining $16,000.

It turns out that Ms. Coyne doesn’t earn enough to borrow through Direct Parent Plus because the program requires that repayments start immediately.

In short, parents with low incomes aren’t eligible for this type of government loan, as a spokeswoman for the U.S. Department of Education confirmed. The Manhattan School of Music refused to answer questions about its financial aid policy.

Another option is a private loan from a bank. But, as the student loan provider Sallie Mae explains on its website, “If you’re a student with little or no credit history, it may be difficult for you to qualify for a loan without a creditworthy co-signer.”

And if your parent has a low income, she may not be eligible to co-sign.

This is the dilemma facing Josh and other young Americans like him. Colleges expect them to borrow, but families don’t earn enough to borrow under federal or private programs.

If the families earned more, they could borrow from Parent Plus (or co-sign their kids’ loan applications), money that students could repay later. The unpleasant truth is that the Education Department is subsidizing loans not for the lowest-income parents, but for the middle and upper classes.

Josh would prefer to earn money rather than borrow. He’d like to perform at corporate events, compose and play at fundraisers. He has already raised thousands of dollars for Haiti earthquake relief efforts and for arts education scholarships for at-risk youth. If you’d like to help Josh, he can be contacted at

Original Source:



Rolling Stone’s University of Virginia Gang Rape Fiction and the Real World
Heather Mac Donald, 03-25-15

The Christie Hiatus
Steven Malanga, 03-23-15

Republicans Want A Better Life For You That Democrats Can't Stand
Diana Furchtgott-Roth, 03-19-15

Manhattan Moment: Medicare's Doctor Payments Mess (and How to Fix It)
Yevgeniy Feyman, 03-19-15

Rules For The Fed To Live By
Charles W. Calomiris, 03-18-15

The Class Gap In Unplanned Babies
Kay S. Hymowitz, 03-17-15

Peak Oil Price? Winners And Losers At The End Of The Era Of The $100 Barrel
Mark P. Mills, 03-17-15

Why A Higher Minimum Wage Will Hurt The Poor
Diana Furchtgott-Roth, 03-17-15


The Manhattan Institute, a 501(c)(3), is a think tank whose mission is to develop and disseminate new ideas
that foster greater economic choice and individual responsibility.

Copyright © 2015 Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, Inc. All rights reserved.

52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10017
phone (212) 599-7000 / fax (212) 599-3494