What death by bureaucratic fiat might look like.
It is very difficult to imagine the country making those decisions just through the normal political channels. And thats part of why you have to have some independent group that can give you guidance.President Barack Obama in a New York Times interview on how costly medical decisions should be made.
The people behind the long table do not know what theyve become. The drug of power has been sugared over in their mouths with a flavoring of righteousness. Someone has to make these decisions, they tell their friends at dinner parties. Its all very difficult for us. But you can see it in their eyes: It isnt really difficult at all. It feels good to them to be the ones who decide.
“Well, we have your doctors recommendation,” says the chairwoman in a friendly tone. She peers over the top of her glasses as she pages through your file.
You have to clear your throat before you can answer. “He says the operation is my only chance.”
“But not really very much of a chance, is it?” she says sympathetically. Over time, shes become expert at sounding sympathetic.
“Seventy percent!” you object.
“Seventy percent chance of survival for five yearsfive years at the outsideand even that only amounts to about 18 months in QALYs: quality-adjusted life years.”
“But without this procedure, Ill be dead before Christmas.”
You try to keep the anger out of your voice. The last thing you want to do is offend them. But the politicians promised youthey promised everyonethere would never be panels like this. They made fun of anyone who said there would. “What do they think were going to do? Pull the plug on grandma?” they chuckled. The media ran news stories calling all rumors of such things “false” or “misleading.” But of course by then the media had become apologists for the state rather than watchdogs for the people.
In fact, the logic of this moment was inevitable. Once government got its fingers on the health-care system, it was only a matter of time before it took it over completely. Now theres one limited pool of dollars while the costs are endless.
“You have the luxury of thinking only of yourself, but we have to think about everyone,” says the professor of ethics. Hes a celebrity and waxes eloquent every Tuesday and Thursday on Bill Maher Tonight. “This isnt the free market, after all. We cant just leave fairness to chance. We have to use reason. Is it better for society as a whole that we allocate limited resources for your operation when we might use the same dollars to bring many more high quality years to someone, say, younger?”
“Im only 62.”
He smiles politely.
“Look, its not just about me,” you argue desperately. “My daughters engaged to get married next year. Shell be heartbroken if Im not there for it.”
“Maybe you should have thought of that before you put on so much weight,” says the medical officer. “I mean, you people have been told time and again . . .”
But the chairwoman is uncomfortable with his censorious tone and cuts him off, saying more gently, “Perhaps your daughter could move the wedding up a little.”
The member in charge of “stakeholder” exceptions shakes her head sadly as she studies your file. “If only you could have checked off one of the boxes. It would be awful if you were penalized just because of a clerical oversight.”
It begins to occur to you that this is how you are going to die: by the fiat of fatuous ideologuesthat is to say, by the considered judgment of a government committee. They are going to snuff you out and never lose a minutes sleep over it, because its only fair, after all.
That logic is implacable too. Free people can treat each other justly, but they cant make life fair. To get rid of the unfairness among individuals, you have to exercise power over them. The more fairness you want, the more power you need. Thus, all dreams of fairness become dreams of tyranny in the end.
You know you should keep your mouth shut. Be humblethey like that. But you speak before you can stop yourself.
“What youre doing here is evil,” you cry out. “Youre trying to take the place of God!”
Original Source: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204683204574356241709682828.html