Manhattan Institute for Policy Research.
search  
 
Subscribe   Subscribe   MI on Facebook Find us on Twitter Find us on Instagram      
 
 
   
 
     
 

New York Post

 

Medical Drama

May 11, 2008

By Paul Howard

Hospital

Man, Woman, Birth, Death, Infinity Plus Red Tape, Bad Behavior, Money, God, and Diversity on Steroids

by Julie Salamon

Penguin Press

"It was crowed, really crowded. A melting pot mayhem - Hasids, Chinese, Pakistanis, Haitians, Russians, Bulgarians." And in the air, "strange spicy odors he couldn't place."

A New York fast food restaurant - or an hospital emergency room?

From journalist Julie Salamon's chronicle of a year in the life of Maimonides Medical Center in Brooklyn, it's hard to tell the difference.

Given unprecedented access to the physicians, administrators and patients at Maimonides, Salamon is out to discover "the financial, ethical, scientific, sociological, personal and cultural matters that determined what kind of care people received."

Her question couldn't be more pressing, as researchers at Dartmouth recently found that Maimonides is one of the nation's most expensive hospitals - at least when it comes to the cost of caring for chronically ill patients.

Medicare spent on average $107,000 per patient for the last two years of their life at Maimonides, compared to $53,000 at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota, $91,000 at New York-Presbyterian and the US average of $46,000. As Congressional Budget Director Peter Orszag asked about the discrepancy, "how can the best medical care in the world cost twice as much as the best medical care in the world?"

The answer is that, in many cases, there's no consensus on how to best treat chronically ill patients. At hospitals like Maimonides, patients may get more care, but they don't necessarily get better care.

Salamon notes Maimonides' decision to open a comprehensive cancer center, complete with a "$5 million linear accelerator for radiation therapy," meant to give the best care, and of course rake in some dollars.

But the center turns out to be a money loser because it isn't getting enough patients referred for radiation treatment - which is reimbursed more generously than chemotherapy. The folly? Before building the center, administrators commissioned a study that found that "only 26 percent of the people in the surrounding area" visited Maimonides for cancer care. The hospital hoped to boost that to 45 percent, but was there really a need, with other hospitals like Memorial Sloan Kettering in the area? Would Maimonides be doing anything other than shifting dollars away from its rivals?

While Salamon praises the work of individual doctors at Maimonides, she notes that insurance plans encourage a system in which patients are rushed out the door like a restaurant turning over tables.

As the chief of surgery relates to her: "You take any two hospitals, if I can do a coronary bypass and get a patient out into a secondary location - home, rehab, family - a day shorter than Lutheran, I've put another $10,000 in my pocket. Every discharge across the board is at least another $10,000 to a hospital."

Everyone at Maimonides feels the pressure to drive turnover. "All these [administrators] crunch numbers every day," a neurosurgeon tells her. "There's a number on your head of how many cases you did in the last month."

Throughout "Hospital", Salamon laments that health care has become a big business. "The system," she writes, "was tainted by callous disregard for decent and equitable care, by money lust, by corporate influence and by lack of political will." At times Salamon suggests that a single payer system would solve these ills - but forgets that Medicare is part of the problem.

Salamon presents Maimonides as a caring institution, run by smart people working under very difficult conditions. But until we have a system that empowers patients and gives hospitals the right incentives to both innovate and save money - as in other sectors of the economy - our health care system will remain maddeningly uneven.

Original Source: http://www.nypost.com/seven/05112008/postopinion/postopbooks/medical_drama_110302.htm

 

 
PRINTER FRIENDLY
 
LATEST FROM OUR SCHOLARS

5 Reasons Janet Yellen Shouldn’t Focus On Income Inequality
Diana Furchtgott-Roth, 10-20-14

Why The Comptroller Race Matters
Nicole Gelinas, 10-20-14

Obama Should Have Picked “Ebola Czar” With Public-Health Experience
Paul Howard, 10-18-14

Success Of Parent Trigger Is Unclear­—Just As Foes Want
Ben Boychuk, 10-18-14

On Obamacare's Second Birthday, Whither The HSA?
Paul Howard, 10-16-14

You Can Repeal Obamacare And Keep Kentucky's Insurance Exchange
Avik Roy, 10-15-14

Are Private Exchanges The Future Of Health Insurance?
Yevgeniy Feyman, 10-15-14

This Nobel Prize-Worthy Economist Figured Out How To Destroy Terrorism
Diana Furchtgott-Roth, 10-15-14

 
 
 

The Manhattan Institute, a 501(c)(3), is a think tank whose mission is to develop and disseminate new ideas
that foster greater economic choice and individual responsibility.

Copyright © 2014 Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, Inc. All rights reserved.

52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10017
phone (212) 599-7000 / fax (212) 599-3494