Civic Report
No. 35 March 2003


Gaining Ground, Moving Up: The Change in the Economic Status of Single Mother Under Welfare Reform

Table 1: Tracking the Poverty Status of Cohorts of Welfare Leavers (Under Three Definitions of Poverty) Using SIPP Panel Data in the Months Before and After Leaving Welfare, 1996–1999

 

 

Months Before Exit

 Six-
month period on welfare before exit

Months After Exit

 

Sample Size

37–42 mths

31–36 mths

25–30 mths

19–24 mths

13–18 mths

7–12 mths

First 6 mths

7–12 mths

13–18 mths

19–24 mths

25–30 mths

31–36 mths

37-42 mths

A: Percent in Poverty based on FAMILY CASH INCOME (excluding EITC)

Cohort leaving welfare after:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

first 6 mths in 1996

121

 

 

 

 

 

 

57.9

51.4

51.7

44.8

44.8

35.0

32.7

31.8

second 6 mths in 1996

98

 

 

 

 

 

69.8

65.8

54.2

61.3

48.2

50.4

50.2

48.0

 

first 6 mths in 1997

150

 

 

 

 

72.0

70.0

67.0

55.9

46.4

53.3

46.4

45.6

  

 

second 6 mths in 1997

80

 

 

 

67.0

76.4

70.7

64.3

64.9

64.6

57.5

55.2

 

  

 

first 6 mths in 1998

140

 

 

60.4

57.6

62.5

63.9

61.9

54.7

51.6

51.9

 

  

 

 

second 6 mths in 1998

80

 

72.6

68.2

74.9

76.2

77.2

73.6

63.4

57.1

 

 

  

 

  

first 6 mths in 1999

100

62.7

67.8

61.9

65.1

68.2

67.8

60.7

51.8

  

 

  

 

  

 

B: Percent in Poverty based on FAMILY CASH INCOME (including EITC) 1)

Cohort leaving welfare after:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

first 6 mths in 1996

121

 

 

 

 

 

 

55.8

42.4

38.6

39.0

40.8

27.2

29.0

24.9

second 6 mths in 1996

98

 

 

 

 

 

67.4

60.3

44.3

53.0

45.2

43.4

40.5

41.5

 

first 6 mths in 1997

150

 

 

 

 

64.6

65.4

62.1

47.7

40.5

45.0

38.7

35.6

  

 

second 6 mths in 1997

80

 

 

 

66.4

71.0

68.1

57.9

55.1

54.9

49.1

38.8

 

  

 

first 6 mths in 1998

140

 

 

57.8

50.3

59.7

58.0

56.7

52.0

46.0

43.1

 

  

 

 

second 6 mths in 1998

80

 

62.6

66.2

69.2

65.8

68.4

62.8

52.6

49.1

  

 

  

 

 

first 6 mths in 1999

100

57.0

62.7

58.9

61.0

61.8

62.4

52.9

46.7

  

 

  

 

  

 

C: Percent in Poverty based on HOUSEHOLD CASH AND NON-CASH INCOME 2)

Cohort leaving welfare after:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

first 6 mths in 1996

121

 

 

 

 

 

 

46.1

30.4

31.2

33.5

28.8

18.8

23.8

19.2

second 6 mths in 1996

  98

 

 

 

 

 

58.2

43.5

32.0

39.7

35.3

36.5

33.3

33.1

 

first 6 mths in 1997

150

 

 

 

 

53.6

52.3

43.7

35.4

30.1

35.6

31.4

28.6

  

 

second 6 mths in 1997

  80

 

 

 

57.5

58.6

55.6

46.7

45.4

46.6

46.6

32.8

 

  

 

first 6 mths in 1998

140

 

 

46.9

39.1

47.3

45.9

45.6

41.2

39.3

38.3

 

  

 

 

second 6 mths in 1998

  80

 

52.3

54.0

51.9

54.8

55.4

43.3

47.7

42.0

  

 

  

 

 

first 6 mths in 1999

100

43.2

43.9

43.9

53.8

50.5

50.8

42.6

38.7

 

 

 

 

 

 

Note: Population restricted to women ages 20–55 (last panel interview) with children under age 18 (in 6-month period before exit) and who did not attrite from the sample in any of the 12 waves. Welfare leavers are those who are observed to be on welfare for at least 4 months out of a 6-month period (the 6-month period on welfare before exit) followed by an 8-month period with at least 4 months off welfare. Some leavers return to welfare in later periods and they are included in the post-exit months. Similarly, the poverty statistics for the 6–42 months prior to exit include all of those in the cohort in that earlier period, whether or not they were on welfare in a particular 6-month period.

1) Includes estimated EITC, excludes all non-cash benefits.
2) Total household cash income plus the value of non-cash benefits and including our estimate of the EITC. Non-cash income aggregates dollar values for food stamps, WIC, and energy assistance. The income of a male partner, if present, is included in household’s income. Information was not available on taxes paid and is excluded.

[Table 1][Table 2][Table 3][Table 4][Table 5][Table 6][Table 7][Table 8]
[
Table 9][Table 10][Table 11][Table 12][Table 13][Table 14]