The Manhattan Institute’s
Center for Rethinking Development
Ideas that shape the city’s planning, housing, and development
Monthly Newsletter

Blight by Government

Julia Vitullo-Martin, December 2008

(©Julia Vitullo-Martin)

What is a neighborhood to do when a government agency holds a major property vacant and deteriorating for years, promising rehabilitation some time in the vague future?

It would be hard to exaggerate the shock of coming unawares upon the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's thirteen-story Board of Transportation Building at 370 Jay Street, standing derelict in the midst of downtown Brooklyn's revival. Despite the pleas of Brooklyn politicians, including then-Councilmember Ken Fisher, the MTA began to empty 370 Jay of its 1,800 employees in 2001—and left it virtually unoccupied and in a state of neglect during a period when so many other buildings and neighborhoods were being rehabilitated and revived. Joe Chan, president of the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership, summarizes, "The MTA has let the building cast a constant shadow of blight on an increasingly revitalized downtown." Michael Gold, general counsel of family-owned Sid's Hardware, directly across the street at 345 Jay, warns, "The disrepair of this building is jeopardizing the further development of downtown Brooklyn." Michael Nill, head of the Brooklyn Friends School located in an elegant building on Pearl Street, at 370 (©Julia Vitullo-Martin) Jay's back, says, "Inside our own buildings all is joyful and celebratory. But what a contrast with outside and the ugliness of the MTA property." Or, as Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz said in late October to The Brooklyn Paper, "For nearly five years, this building has been vacant, an empty shell amid the teeming life of the neighborhood and devoid of people, the area around the building has become a magnet for trash. If people's initial taste of Brooklyn is a smelly subway stop and a dark, empty, trash-strewn plaza, it can't help but color their impression." Indeed, Markowitz has been officially complaining about the site for most of his borough presidency. In 2002 he extracted a promise from then-Transit Authority President Lawrence Reuter to renovate 370 Jay Street and the underlying subway station together. Neither has been done.

The building was not always ugly. Indeed, it had its admirers, including the eminent urban commentator Lewis Mumford, whom architectural historian Francis Morrone, in the New York Sun, quoted as saying that it "set the right precedent for a modern office building, and I am hopeful that its sobriety and efficiency will leave a mark on the whole neighborhood." It has, alas, left its mark as a result of the MTA's (©Julia Vitullo-Martin) neglect. Designed by architects William Haugaard and Andrew Thomas and opened in 1950, the modernist tower was the place "where, once upon a time, all the city's subway tokens made their way via the night trains that collected the tokens from turnstiles," Morrone wrote. Mumford particularly liked its dimensions—356 feet along Jay Street and 82 feet on Willoughby—which he regarded as ideal for a "building that is intended to rely upon natural lighting and natural ventilation." It was a sort of early, pre-LEED green building. Another modernist feature, its elevation on one-story piers, has been less successful, creating a dark, dank public space that leads down to the important Jay Street-Borough Hall subway station below—itself a disgraceful mess of broken steps, peeling paint, plywood dividers, graffiti and vandalism.

The MTA, which has possession of 370 Jay Street under its master lease with the city, has kept it nearly vacant for several years, despite interest from respectable groups like the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership in using it. In the meantime, the agency signed a long-term, extraordinarily expensive $1.6 billion lease for lavish headquarters for itself and New York City Transit at 2 Broadway, in Lower Manhattan. After hundreds of millions of dollars in cost (©Julia Vitullo-Martin) overruns during renovation, the MTA decided to keep its own headquarters on Madison Avenue in Midtown. Meanwhile, largely emptied of its New York City Transit staff, 370 Jay languished along with its neighborhood—a sorry tale of waste and profligacy.

The MTA is again promising to spend $150 million on renovating 370 Jay, perhaps reoccupying the building by 2016. But its own 2008-2013 proposed capital program for 370 Jay is deeply inadequate. It notes that 418,000 square feet are vacant today and that under Phase I, which was supposed to have already begun but hasn't, it would renovate and open up to 100,000 square feet by 2011. But the neighborhood almost surely won't get even that. Phase II (2012-2015) depends on "early relocation if able to buyout/sublease." In other words, the MTA's plan is contingent upon its being able to move employees to 370 Jay from various offices in Brooklyn and Queens where it is now paying rent. But the office market has turned down, with the result that many landlords will be reluctant to let the MTA out of its leases cheaply. Those leases now cost the MTA some $7 million, which is the amount of money the agency is hoping to save each year after reopening 370 Jay.

(©Julia Vitullo-Martin)


So why not go with the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership plan, which urges the MTA to net-lease just eight of 370 Jay Street's thirteen floors to a private developer, which would in turn lease them to many small businesses? Doing this would save the MTA upwards of $120 million in capital funds, says Joe Chan, while helping revitalize the neighborhood with small, creative businesses, and responding to an economic demand that is now going unmet. Under this plan the MTA would still have 150,000 square feet for its own uses. But as Brooklyn Councilmember David Yassky points out, "The MTA says they're going to spend $150 million to reoccupy the building—assuming they do it on budget, obviously a faulty assumption—in order to save rent of $180 million over the life of the leases. Hey, we're going to save $30 million! For $30 million they’ve done this to the neighborhood? Something is really wrong."

(©Julia Vitullo-Martin)

A long-time advocate of public transportation, Yassky has repeatedly asked the MTA for an accounting of the value and use of all its properties, which the MTA refuses to supply. The MTA asserts that, first, it "is continually assessing its real estate to identify properties, like the Hudson Yards, that can provide revenue to the MTA without disrupting service." Second, "These opportunities are limited because so much of the MTA's real estate is operated under master lease, wherein it can only be used by the MTA for transportation purposes." In other words, the MTA is worried that if it were to respond to the partnership's net-lease proposal, for example, it would endanger its lease arrangement with the city—which might well demand 370 Jay back. Thus it simply keeps 370 Jay vacant—no non-transportation use, no problem.

Perhaps the city should take the property back so that it could issue an RFP for its economically strongest use, which may indeed be the (©Julia Vitullo-Martin) partnership's vision of a small business incubator. After all, Mayor Bloomberg hates waste. Early in his administration he issued a directive to all city agencies to identify and analyze their real estate holdings so that they could sell off or exchange unproductive land. Even better, the administration could heed Yassky's suggestion to sell 370 Jay to a private developer, which would put it back on the tax rolls (the MTA, of course, pays not a penny in taxes on its property) and "lead the way to the ongoing development of downtown Brooklyn."

Meanwhile, the building declines and Lewis Mumford's optimistic prediction—that 370 Jay "might easily become a model for a whole district of such structures planned for efficient work, for easy access to public transportation, and for convenient pedestrian circulation"—seems of another age altogether.

The optimism of an earlier age has given way to regret. "In the building as a whole there is not a single false touch," says Morrone. "I've grown to love it."

There's nothing next short of some powerful political entity pushing the MTA off the dime. The MTA's plan is simply to wait, ignoring the protests of elected officials and local businesses and letting the building and its block deteriorate. Says the partnership's Joe Chan, "We're not trying to be unnecessarily punitive. But we are frustrated that the MTA has refused to engage in any meaningful dialogue regarding the productive reuse of that building or its capacity to address their financial situation. We have repeatedly tried to engage them at multiple points at multiple levels but not been invited to participate in the dialogue about the building's future." It would be hard to exaggerate the anger of local residents and activists. "Slowly over the years, we transformed Brooklyn into this very desirable place," says Angel Zimick, head of the greening committee for the Friends School. "But this building is a slap in the face to our sense of pride of place. It is insulting to all the people who worked so hard and who were extremely proud to say they lived in Brooklyn." She would like to see the city sell 370 Jay Street to a private owner: "Any good developer—fill in the blank—would do something useful with that building. It just needs love and care and attention."

The MTA is a state agency—but one that needs substantial financial support and cooperation from the city government. The Bloomberg administration should make the productive reuse of 370 Jay a top priority in future negotiations. If it does not, the MTA will continue to undermine downtown Brooklyn for years to come.


December 2008
Downtown Brooklyn Partnership
Brooklyn Paper
Brooklyn Friends School
Brooklyn Borough President
Councilmember David Yassky
Welcome to Brooklyn
Brooklyn On Line
Brooklyn Tourism
Brooklyn Museum
MTA—Please Fix Jay
Madoff Scandal Shaking Real Estate Industry
Brrr! Icy January for Manhattan
Schumer Seeks Protection for Apartment Buildings Facing Default
Council Set to Approve Higher Hotel and Property Taxes
Preservationists See Bulldozers Charging Through a Loophole
Preservation and Development, Engaged in a Delicate Dance
Port Authority Plans No Cuts in Tough Economy
Crisis or Not, Sticking to the PlaNYC
Houses of Worship Choosing to Avoid Landmark Status
Owner Chops, But Can't Undermine, Landmark Status
Judge Rules Against City and Allows Church to Lease Its Building to a Catering Company
Audit: NYCHA Capital Program in Trouble
New York City's Public Housing Chief to Step Down
Can Private Methods Save Public Housing?
Report Cites Problems in Elevator Where Boy Died
Feud Between City Agencies Delays Moderate-Cost Housing
Advocates Question Hunter's Point South Financing
Volunteer Shelter Network Up in Arms over Changes
The Mayor's Budget-Cutting Strategy
From the West Side: A Roadmap for City Streets
Fordham vs. the Upper West Side
Working for a Greener Harlem
Taking a Stroll Along the High Line
Permit Mill Slows Down: Census Pegs Drop in New Building at 88 Percent
Building Permits Plunge in NYC
Atlantic Yards at 5: What Went Wrong?
Atlantic Yards Becomes a Question Mark
For Reinvention, Red Hook Follows Its Roots
In Bed-Stuy Residents Ask: What's Up at the Armory?
After 146 Years, a Brooklyn Convent is Closing
Cleric Who Fought Land Deal Axed
Rezoning Too Late for Brighton Beach?
Stimulus Money: The Downturn's Silver Lining?
Water Plant's Rising Tide
Public Housing and Public Schools: How do Students Living in NYC Public Housing Fare in School?
Hunger & Homelessness Survey: A Status Report on Hunger & Homelessness in America's Cities
The Bloomberg Administration's Plan to Reduce Emergency Shelter for Street Homeless New Yorkers
New York State Commission on Property Tax Relief Final Report to Gov. Paterson
Confronting the Housing Squeeze: Challenges Facing Immigrant Tenants, and What New York Can Do
Transforming Foreclosed Properties Into Community Assets
Report to Gov. Paterson from the Commission on MTA Financing
The State of the City's Economy & Finances, 2008
New York City Unemployment in 2009: The Emerging Crisis
Sustainable Streets Index 2008
NextAmericanCity: NYC Neighborhood Gets a Transportation Makeover
The Real Deal: Development in Distress
City Room: Details on St. Vincent's Tower Divide Panel
City Room: No Trompe-l'Oeil—A Muralist Loses His View
The Daily Beast: New York's Impending Real Estate Doom
City Room: Numbers Vary on Homeless Veterans
CUF: Q&A with Eldon Scott, Founder of the Union Square Holiday Market
Runnin' Scared: E-mails Show City's Tricky Math in Yankee Stadium Deal
DDDB: Happy Fifth Landgrabiversary, Atlantic Yards Gehry Lays Off Atlantic Yards Staff
Atlantic Yards Report: How Forest City Pursues More Aid
City Room: Reaction to Ravitch’s MTA Report
If you would like to unsubscribe, please reply to us and type "Unsubscribe" in the subject line.